Subscribe to FineScale ModelerSubscribe todayRenew onlineGive a gift!
We have made some big changes at FineScale.com.  Learn More.
FineScale.com forums are FREE. If you wish to participate you must LOGIN | REGISTER.
Welcome to FineScale.com Forums   Faq | Login | Register  

General Modeling Discussion

Started by Variant at 01-22-2009 10:28 AM. Topic has 57 replies.
  Page 1 of 3 (58 items) 1 2 3 >
Print Search
Sort Posts:    
   01-22-2009, 10:28 AM
Variant

Joined on 01-09-2008
Posts 5
What's the worst kit you've ever built?
I have to ask this question, because for me, I think it's the kit I'm currently working on.  The Revell-Monogram 1/48 P-38 Lightning.  I stupidly bought this on impulse from a local craft store, and after getting halfway through the build and getting fed up with nonstop fitment issues, I came here and did a search, and saw that this kit is almost universally despised.  After reading what other people have said about it, I've decided to persevere and use this build as a "learning experience".  If nothing else, I'm sure my puttying and seam-filling skills will be much improved after dealing with this monster!

What about you guys?  What's the absolute worst experience you've ever had with a build?
   Report Abuse 
   01-22-2009, 11:52 AM
Rob Gronovius


Joined on 12-03-2002
Fort Knox
Posts 5,195
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
A couple of kits live at the top of my perpetual list of bad kits I've attempted to build. The first was the Zvezda T-60 Soviet light tank. The other is the Trumpeter M60A3, a poor copy of the Tamiya kit.
   Report Abuse 
   01-22-2009, 5:32 PM
Joe Montanti

Joined on 03-10-2005
Posts 49
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
1/48 F-82 twin Mustang. I knew what I was getting into but wanted to hone my skills. I did a creditable job but it was tough. Nothing fit and the canopies were way to thick.  
   Report Abuse 
   01-22-2009, 8:31 PM
2/20 Bluemax


Joined on 02-24-2007
S.E. Michigan
Posts 138
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

The one I'm currently working on(waiting for some warm weather so I can paint) a 1963 vintage Revell F4U-4 corsair. I've had to rework/redo/make just about everything. 'Course it only cost me $7.00. No cockpit detail(wrong anyway), LG just sticks and globs of plastic, no wheelwells. most panel lines wrong, I could go on and on.

Jim

   Report Abuse 
   01-23-2009, 10:45 AM
upnorth


Joined on 12-12-2002
Canada / Czech Republic
Posts 2,639
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

Pretty much anything pre 1990 that had the Hobbycraft label on it.  They cleaned up their act around then (I think that's when they hooked up with Academy). Prior to that they pirated a lot of other folk's kits and generally churned out total crap.

Notable pre 1990 Hobbycraft kits I attempted but gave up on:

1/72 S-2F Tracker:

Bad copy of the Hasegawa kit with serious mold mismatches on the landing gear legs. 

 

1/72 FW-190A:

No idea where they got the tooling for it, but it was total garbage in every concievable way.

 

1/72 Sukhoi SU-17 Fitter:

A total joke of a kit and excedingly innacurate representation of the subject even considering that it was made while the Iron Curtain was still up. 

 

The worst kit that I ever saw through to completion would have to have been the old Revell 1/48 F-16A kit from the early 80s. Horrible fit issues everywhere. A Number of years later I bought Revell's 1/48 F-16 ADF kit only to find the old F-16A molds along with a new sprue of parts to make it look like an ADF. It went straight to spares when I saw that.

   Report Abuse 
   01-23-2009, 2:43 PM
cwalker3


Joined on 08-17-2004
Forest Hill, Maryland
Posts 399
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
RPM Minenraumer. Terrible kit. Warped parts. Lousy fit. Horrible instructions. But every time I see one for sale I want to get it because it's such an unusual subject.
   Report Abuse 
   01-23-2009, 4:10 PM
tankboy51

Joined on 09-28-2004
Denver
Posts 190
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

The DML Horten flying wing thing the Germans did.  Just couldn' get the thing together.  I still have it in a slightly assembled state.  Had to walk away before it became little tiny pieces.  I don't think that all the engine stuff will fit in it with the wings on.  I couldn't build it.. but I did get the RPM Minenraumer built.  A buddy helped me figure out the wheel pads.  He figured it out in about 10 seconds.  Genius.  The rest, well I replaced the turret with a Italeri one. Don't remember much else about it.

Doug

   Report Abuse 
   01-25-2009, 9:55 AM
mapguy


Joined on 12-12-2003
Upstate NY
Posts 53
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
Any 1:72 Airfix kit. Although the 1:48 Hobbycraft Arrow comes close.
   Report Abuse 
   01-25-2009, 10:34 AM
DURR


Joined on 04-08-2003
mass usa
Posts 2,883
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

Mpm kits   though some say they are ok in the last 3 or so yrs

but the earlier ones  like the reppu

i had more filler than plastic   

if the model is real cheap$$  hey thats ok     one does not expect a cheapie to be good ( i am not saying that all the cheapies are bad   some are really good for short money)                                  

 

 

but when it is a mid to high price kit

2 things

either the modeler is nuts  or the manufacturer s/b out of business





   Report Abuse 
   01-25-2009, 10:36 AM
Mike S.


Joined on 05-15-2006
USA
Posts 203
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
I agree, many of the 60's era 1/72nd Airfix kits were dogs, but some can be gems in disguise (especially in the 1/48th range). However, nothing comes close to some of those old, horrible Frog and Matchbox kits in my book.
   Report Abuse 
   01-25-2009, 11:00 AM
Summit


Joined on 10-29-2007
Inland Northwest
Posts 2,072
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

 Mike S. wrote:
I agree, many of the 60's era 1/72nd Airfix kits were dogs, but some can be gems in disguise (especially in the 1/48th range). However, nothing comes close to some of those old, horrible Frog and Matchbox kits in my book.

Accck Shock [:O]  - those are my most favorites to build.  I would take them any day over a Trumpeter aircraft kit. The Corsair F4U-4 total waste of plastic ! I regret ever buying their over priced kits even with an employee discount at the Hobby Shop. The other Trump kits I had went to ebay starting at .99 cents. 


Sean
"I've reached nearly fifty years of age with my system."
Weekend GB 2008
   Report Abuse 
   01-26-2009, 12:34 PM
Mike H.


Joined on 11-16-2006
Posts 169
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
Polar Light's "Undertaker" show dragster.  Poor fit on everything darn near.  Especially when it came to mating the body & chassis.
   Report Abuse 
   01-26-2009, 4:22 PM
subfixer


Joined on 03-09-2004
Hampton Roads, Virginia
Posts 3,340
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
Every 1/48 scale Aurora aircraft model I ever came across during the sixties. The things had locator outlines for almost every decal.

I'm from the government and I'm here to help.

   Report Abuse 
   01-26-2009, 5:38 PM
Mike S.


Joined on 05-15-2006
USA
Posts 203
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

 Summit wrote:
Accck Shock [:O]  - those are my most favorites to build.  I would take them any day over a Trumpeter aircraft kit. The Corsair F4U-4 total waste of plastic ! I regret ever buying their over priced kits even with an employee discount at the Hobby Shop. The other Trump kits I had went to ebay starting at .99 cents. 

Don't get me wrong, I'm a BIG fan of Airfix (those Multipose and carded 54mm figures were some of the best value to come along, for example), but there are some serious dogs in there, no question. One that stands out is the 1/72nd 262, simply dreadful.

Matchbox has it's devoted fan base, however I've never found them endearing.

IMO Frog are the pits, flat out.Yuck [yuck]

As I have said elsewhere before, I am no fan of Trumpeter. They have a few kits that stand out as good quality, but most are lacking (especially considering the average price they sell for). Some are far BELOW par (1/32nd P-40, terrible figure kits).

   Report Abuse 
   01-26-2009, 10:47 PM
tigerman


Joined on 03-06-2003
Rain USA, Vancouver WA
Posts 14,250
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
Esci Demag in 1/35. One of the few kits that I trashed.


Eric
"It is well that war is so terrible, lest we grow too fond of it."-R.E.Lee
   Report Abuse 
   01-27-2009, 1:05 PM
Hans von Hammer


Joined on 06-26-2008
Iowa
Posts 5,756
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

 subfixer wrote:
Every 1/48 scale Aurora aircraft model I ever came across during the sixties. The things had locator outlines for almost every decal.

Ditto Aurora, specifically their 1/48th P-61... Absolute POS from every possible aspect...

Liked their WW1 birds though, but I gotta admit, I blew up at least five of the Yellow Zekes and couple of the metallic red Me 109s...



Colonel, 55th FG
Great Plains Wing
Commemorative Air Force
   Report Abuse 
   02-01-2009, 4:39 PM
arki30


Joined on 02-01-2004
Second City
Posts 2,053
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

Premiere BAe Hawk T.1.  Holy moly, what a crummy kit.  Only build I have stopped and tossed in the trash.


Building Now:
1/48 Trumpeter Dolphin HH-65C (IMS 3 GB) - 70%

Upcoming:
1/48 Hasegawa A-7E Corsair II
1/48 Hasegawa Fw-190A-4 (Winter Warriors II GB)
Random Thoughts:
Experience is something you don't get until just after you need it.
   Report Abuse 
   02-01-2009, 8:35 PM
Glamdring


Joined on 02-25-2005
Nashotah, WI
Posts 992
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

 Variant wrote:
The Revell-Monogram 1/48 P-38 Lightning. 

You just nailed it right there.  That is without a doubt the worst kit I had the misfortune to buy.  I made the mistake of performing the surgery to do the night fighter version as well, that compounded the misery.

I have seen it built into a decent rendition once, but the builder spent so much time on it that it just wasn't worth it in the end.


Robert

And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.

Badge of Fame and/or Shame
   Report Abuse 
   02-03-2009, 8:12 AM
Hans von Hammer


Joined on 06-26-2008
Iowa
Posts 5,756
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?

I actually love the Monogram P-38...  Never had any real problems with it other than a bit of filler...

Wanna hunt down another one...



Colonel, 55th FG
Great Plains Wing
Commemorative Air Force
   Report Abuse 
   02-03-2009, 4:42 PM
Glamdring


Joined on 02-25-2005
Nashotah, WI
Posts 992
Re: What's the worst kit you've ever built?
 Hans von Hammer wrote:

I actually love the Monogram P-38...  Never had any real problems with it other than a bit of filler...

Wanna hunt down another one...

There were 3 at my local Michael's when I was there on Friday...that doesn't help you, but...


Robert

And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.

Badge of Fame and/or Shame
   Report Abuse 
  Page 1 of 3 (58 items) 1 2 3 >
FineScale.com Forums » General Discussion » General Modeling Discussion Forum Jump:

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems