Jack,
Just some personal thoughts, NOT recommendations.
Contractor type compressors from hardware, DIY stores: I have a Husky with a 3 gal tank which I bought at Lowes. Don't remember but I think it was $70. It works fine as an AB compressor IF noise is not a problem. Adjustable pressure to over 100 PSI and down to zero but so noisy that it scares the bejeezus out of me when it turns on. Works fine, just noisy. Works great for light duty air hammers and filling your tires too.
Harbor Freight compressors: I have the 1/8 hp model and have used it for over three years with no problems. It is quiet enough (you can hold a conversation while it's running) but, depending on AB pressure, depress the AB trigger and it cycles every fraction of a second or so. With the regulator and a 10 ft AB hose I didn't notice any pulsing. It's still working fine. Mine does not get hot with normal (me normal?) use.
BUT, for the reasons mentioned by Milairjunkie I wanted an AB compressor with a tank. I thought about adding a tank to the HF compressor as KeiLau has done with his compressor but when Amazon had the TC910 for $180 less than MSRP I went for it. So,what did I get? A compressor that meets my WANTS. It's quiet, fills to capacity in a little over a minute, sits quietly on the bench until I use it, cycles every few minutes rather than seconds and has been working fine.
BUT now, I think I want a twin with a tank and Dixie Arts price is tempting. The quest never ends!