Sergeant
Gamera
Steve Zaloga had a great article on olive drab but last time I looked for it I couldn't find it online so I'm guessing he wanted it taken down.
I believe he called for mixing two parts Tamiya US olive drab to one part Tamiya German panzer yellow for a pretty good match. That's off the top of my head though, I do have the article at home and I'll try to remember to look for it.
Gamera, I read Steve’s article and that’s where I came up with my first paint formula of Tamiya XF-62 Olive Drab with 25% to 35% XF-60 Dark Yellow (German Panzer yellow). I did not see any difference between 25% and 35% dark yellow; however, the end results were good to my eyes. They are shown above in my first post showing four spoons. The problem is I believe Tamiya has changed their XF-62 since Steve published his article and without a paint sample from him I have no way to compare my results.
Its been suggested I decide what looks good to me and go with it because after the weathering and camouflage the O.D. will look different anyway.
Sorry, guess I ended up telling you something you already know. That's what I get from skimming though the forum at lunch and then posting...
Personally, I've been using Vallejo's olive drab primer, it comes in a larger bottle than what James listed. It's probably the same shade though I am not sure. AK Interactive makes a simular item.
I pre-shade the vehicle with AK Interactive's olive drab colour modulation set. It comes with six small dropper bottles that contain two darker shadow shades, a straight olive drab, and three lighter highlight shades to apply where sunlight would hit the top surfaces. A lot of people hate the colour modulation technique calling it silly and overdone, personally I like it since it adds some colour variation to a single colour subject. It's a matter of personal taste.
And at that I agree totally with you- the correct colour is the one that looks right to you. I'm running off at the mouth but it seems you're happy with what you have so you should probably just go with it.