Personally ;
The North Carolina by Trumpeter was my first of their kits .
Rather than argue the accuracy of the kit with someone who didn't have one , I went to the source . Yes , the Ship Museum itself . They stated the following . "If it wasn't accurate as the ship floats RIGHT NOW , we would NOT carry it in the gift shop ! ".
Now , I will admit , being a shipmodeler from Noah's time saved my butt ! Partway through the early part of the build they have you put on part of the upperworks plus the deck . Then turn it over and install the completed ship bottom of your choice . Kinda backwards that was !
The kit gave no more confusing instruction that I could find , Eduard P.E. and Done . She has a place of honor in a friend's home !