Moderator Status.....?

now how would the powers above choose                 

 some honorable people would be left out

to my mind some of the best people out here are at the complete polar opposites  (no names) but some are Xtreme libral  some Xtreme conserv. in views  and as i say they are some of my fav people ,they because of their Xtreme views either way   they would be bad choices

is is a play favorites game

is it a # of posts status

i think my ?'s are reasonable

and bg, even with a) human behavior dictates they would/could eventually be "corrupted"! its just how people are...you cant change that because people WANT a position of power. im sure you've heard people say (a million times or more) if i was in charge i'd do things differently...yeah...they always do/would! see you give a humbled person who has nothing and he will remain humbled because he has lived it everyday. you give someone who desires wealth and power a "fix" and they corrupt the whole system. dont believe me...look at pta's, look at home owner's associations, look at unions, look at city halls, look at mayors, look at congress, look at general's, look at other countries. blah blah blah!! btw, i was only trying to suppliment your point bg not make it look like i was trying to convince you. that said, i think it doesnt matter. the staff will do what they need to and im just wasting my breathe/fingers here...i still think its a bad idea but i will leave this alone as im not trying to make enemies here.

The only way I know of to have moderators that aren't petty and corrupt would be to have either: a) moderators whose livlihood (or something equally weighty) relies on their doing a top-notch, professional, honest job, or b) have moderators who are detached and disinterested in  what the forum has to offer.  We already have a) to some extent since the owners are de-facto moderators.  I'm not sure how you could accomplish b) without it turning into some permutation of a).

your asking them to prevent the very thing they would create!!! once created, how would you stop it? if done correctly (as they are currently doing...because there aren't any) they wouldnt need to moderate moderators! if you dont believe me...let it happen...give people just that 1" of power...watch and see...! ask yourself this too...remember when you were a kid...did ya ever fight to be the captain...of ANYTHING? dont tell me ya havent...but if so, maybe think harder about all the other times like it...you'd probably surprise yourself while proving my point! i dont know...just my thoughts as always (not that ya asked).

BGuy wrote:

On a similar note, I couldn't help notice that somebody has *deleted* the thread where people were asking--repeatedly--for FSM to do another article on injected molded plastic model production.

This is another reason trusted forum moderators are needed. They can moderate the moderators, and prevent a monopoly/dictatorship.

camo junkie wrote:

personally mg, while i dont cause trouble and certainly wouldnt think of it (i like it here and the people and staff), i cant help but wonder if this should be done. its that whole give a man a little power and he takes over the world mentality. im not saying someone here would...but human behavior dictates they would. then who decides when people are getting out of line or causing trouble or whatever. i think personally there would be more headaches then help with this scenario. however, this isnt my decision...i'm just throwing the (hopefully) obvious out there! for some reason its what i do!

I've seen forum moderators go overboard in other places, causing either a) the forum owners to have to police the forum even more than before or b) the owners withdraw, the corrupt moderators rule and complaints to the owner are ignored.

On a similar note, I couldn't help notice that somebody has *deleted* the thread where people were asking--repeatedly--for FSM to do another article on injected molded plastic model production.

personally mg, while i dont cause trouble and certainly wouldnt think of it (i like it here and the people and staff), i cant help but wonder if this should be done. its that whole give a man a little power and he takes over the world mentality. im not saying someone here would...but human behavior dictates they would. then who decides when people are getting out of line or causing trouble or whatever. i think personally there would be more headaches then help with this scenario. however, this isnt my decision...i'm just throwing the (hopefully) obvious out there! for some reason its what i do!

Kelly Shaw wrote:

Thanks for the question. FSM does have the capability to tap forum moderators. Many of our sister publications (eg. Modelrailroader) have already done so, and we're currently considering it. Kelly, FSM

Thanks for taking the time to read my question and to answer it. It's also great to hear the FSM is currently considering forum members as moderators.

Thanks for the question.

FSM does have the capability to tap forum moderators. Many of our sister publications (eg. Modelrailroader) have already done so, and we're currently considering it.

Kelly, FSM