you can use two different colors of paint and a gentle sandpapering.
Here is an extreme case, but it illustrates the method.
I have a plastic Pierced Steel Planking aircraft base. It needs to be steel, with mud showing through the hundreds of holes, and along each strip's joint line.
so, paint the base with my steel, and patches of rust, etc,,,,,,until it looks like weathered steel planking before the mud. spray a light coat of the mud color all over the base.
then carefully and lightly wet sand off the mud on the high spots or anywhere else I don't want it. everywhere I sand on the mud, the steel will show through.
after it looks like you want it, seal it with a clear coat (flat or satin, whatever you want)
it is a variation of the method used to paint the raised letters on real life engine valve covers, but, it works better and faster on model parts with hobby paints.
Rex