One of their older kits... LMAO... yeah, it is one of the first in the 'resurgance line', as I like to call it, so I guess you could say it's 'old'...
Anyhoo, it's a dang nice kit. I haven't finished mine yet but so far no real problems. There are some outline and shape problems but that's for the rivet counters to debate. The one thing I don't like is the two-piece canopy, but that's just a personal preference.
Sounds like the kit you have is one of the plated editions. Tamiya released a few of their kits as plated editions, the P-51 and the F-84 coming to mind. But the majority of the kits were unplated.
As to the Trumpeter kit, I've only seen it; never owned, much less built, one. It's supposed to be more accurate in shape and outline, but I dunno about that fersher. As to fit, I saw a couple reviews on the kit and there were no real big complaints that I recall. One of those reviews was online but I can't find it at the moment; may be gone now. I grabbed some images from that review but didn't keep the url. Oh well...
If I had to choose between the two right now, I'd pick Tamiya. But I'd like to grab a Trumpeter kit to see how it compares. It do look nice built up...
Here's a couple scans of Aeromaster sheets with a few interesting schemes to get you thinking...
Direct Link
Direct Link
Fade to Black...