Hi Ben,,, I saw your post and began reading (and enjoying) this morning ,,, ouch, sorry to hear about the new chew toy for your pup (I have labs, I understand,, )
Hope you are able to somewhat salvage and good luck with the replacement... Oh, while you are out you might want to pick up a nyla-bone or some other suitable dog chew toy for your pup..... ya don't want him/her getting into the habit of using your kits for toys!! Yikes!
Best of luck