New to WW2 modeling -- but how are you at complex and delicate parts (albeit very accurate)? Or would you like another go at a Tamiya (i.e. good engineering, good parts fit, good instructions, solid but not super detailed/accurate)?
If the former, then I recommend a Tasca/Asuka Sherman kit (for an experienced modeler).
If you want simpler, then go with Tamiya M4A3 kit or Tamiya M4A3 (105) "assault" tank (just leave off the add-on side armor).