Shine? Figures should be matt. Clothing, cotton, wool, hair, fur, buckskin have minimal gloss. Silk and satin should have a sheen. Leather can have semi gloss to gloss depending on age or be flat if it's well worn or sueded. Eyes can be glossed if they are big enough. The only figures that should be glossed are a very specific style of lead toy soldiers.
If this is the old Aurora mold form the mid 60's, IIRC, he's wearing only a pair of torn pants. The only gloss here might be on his teeth, if they're showing, and eyes. You could do his nails/claws semi gloss.