Thanks for the kind words!
It sure could be a GUP, no idea what boat, stumbled across it recently. The gearing and supports look pretty close to the Navpers 16016 1950s manual, so it was a Gato/Balao at one time at least.
Torp Shutters - yes, spot on. Go to http://amp.rokket.biz/reference.shtml there's a list ("Gato Torpedo Shutters") of many boats with confirmed and suspected shutter styles ("Valley" is what we have termed the long scoop). Growler is confirmed Valley in the bow, and based on 214 and others in that series by EB, strong likelihood Valley in the stern.Then there's the actually rare "spoon" style (Revell kit, and NOT the Cobia!!!), and the flat/angle style "Balao".
Haddock just not enough evidence, but suspect from lack of curving either Spoon or Balao.
Accurate Model Parts have a spoon resin set for the bow, and have almost completed mold master for the Balao style, and have drawings for Valley scoopy style, hopefully will be available soon.
http://amp.rokket.biz/am_1_72_gato_sets.shtml
This is great stuff as Eric says, building on info!
Cheers,
Wink
AMP - Accurate Model Parts
Fabric Flags, AM Uboat Goodies & More
http://amp.rokket.biz/