SEARCH FINESCALE.COM

Enter keywords or a search phrase below:

In-box review of the Trump's new U.S.S. Freedom, LCS-1.

2596 views
5 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    August 2005
  • From: EG48
Posted by Tracy White on Monday, November 7, 2011 12:16 AM

He didn't have to spend the time he did writing up his in-box review, so I'm not going to call it worthless. Stick out tongue

Thanks for that; while I"m not a big fan of the boat I might still wind up with one....

Tracy White Researcher@Large

  • Member since
    August 2008
Posted by tankerbuilder on Sunday, November 6, 2011 2:57 PM

GEE , I didn,t know that it came out in 1/350 , Even my LHS missed the bus here . The 1/700 version sure looks tiny ! I have started my 1/350 INDEPENDENCE and I tell you I have spent three days figuring out ways to correct the side to side and bow to stern warps .They are bad !! ANYWAY. I guess i feel the same way .Don,t tell us about the parts , tell us how it goes together and what problems or lack of problems you had building it .My biggest problem is not knowing how to send pictures .I am going to the BEST BUY and see if someone can sit down and show me how .  Anyway, Can you believe the difference between the two ?I wonder, is it going to be like the TUCUMCARI and her competition or the CROCKETT class gunboats that NEVER lived up to the hype ! If the F-22 and F-35 cost 425 million apiece how much is being wasted on these ships ? There,s where the GOVERNMENT could save lots . Let the private sector come up with a workable ship or plane and then lets see . BUT no more excessive costs.(I bet with the private sector the cost overuns would be miniscule compared to government projects !! ) yes they are strange ships and that goes without saying . Let,s see the build in progress okay? Thank you for what you did have to say though.I do appreciate that.          tankerbuilder

  • Member since
    March 2005
Posted by dzhou on Saturday, November 5, 2011 3:31 AM

The comparison is only for what is avalible in the freedom contrasted with the Independence kit, vice versa. It's not a ship to ship comparison. That would be silly since both, although has the LCS name, are designed for different aspect of the Littoral" mission. I was just comparing the different options offered, EX. Freedom has clear windows, independence don''t. Independence kit has those tie down rings, Freedom doesn't. etc.

Oh yeah, got more serious comparison between the two kits, have to say, the Freedom is A LOT, and I mean A LOOOOOTTTT more complex than the Independence with what look like twice if not more small parts for details so do becareful. I will try for a build review but damn it, that may happen at a tortoise or even slower than a tortoise pace cause 1.  I got what feels like 8 different projects going on at once. 2.  Work is seriously a mood killer, 3. SWMBO right now is always on my case because of reason 4. 4. I just got a 3 week old son...and that last one is the penultimate of all penultimate modeling making killer it seems! (When the little tyke wakes up 2AM in morning cause he soiled his diapers...GRRRRRRRRRRRRRR)!

On the Bench: Man, Choices, Choices...Where to start. But trying to close up shop on the Trumpeter F4F-3 (Early) Wildcat. On the Stash: Trumpeter's TBM-3 Avenger, Revell's C-17, Trumpeter's 1/32 Typhoon, Trumpeter's SBD-3 Dauntless, and waiting for my BR-86 to arrive In the "Spare Parts" Heap: Dragon's 1/32 P-51D Mustang Early Version (Worst kit I ever saw. Wasted $35 bucks! Ohh Well)!!!
  • Member since
    August 2005
  • From: Sydney, Australia
Posted by Phil_H on Saturday, November 5, 2011 12:48 AM

Why all the comparisons with the Independence? Independence is a very different ship - about all the two have in common is the "LCS" designation.

  • Member since
    March 2007
  • From: Carmel, CA
Posted by bondoman on Friday, November 4, 2011 11:55 PM

Build it and report. In box reviews are worthless.

  • Member since
    March 2005
In-box review of the Trump's new U.S.S. Freedom, LCS-1.
Posted by dzhou on Friday, November 4, 2011 2:48 AM

1/350 scale of course. Great compliment to your Trump or Bronco 1/350 LCS-2 U.S.S. Independence.

1.st of all,  this ship was alot more expensive than the Indepence. I got Independence in China for like less than $15, this ship cost me $30. But still pretty cheap consideringly.

The kit is proto-typical trumpeter. The kit contains 530 pieces on 8 sprues, upper and lower hull, single piece hull deck,  various pieces of Photo-etch (details for stuff like the Sea Ram, netting and handrails). a decal sheet and a 29 step instruction book.

Now, don't know the accuracy of the kit and don't care. IT looks like a Freedom and that's good enough for me. But anyways...

The major differences this time, when compared to the Indepence, there are several open areas of the ship that you can display open to show off the ship's innards, these include: The quick on, quick off Zodiac special forces bay at the rear, this is a detailed unit with a side bay, control room, two zodiac boats, one on a "launcher", the other in storage. It look pretty good, but of course, anyone want to go to town can add more details on this, if they can find any refrence for this.

The biggest difference, and disspointed some people, was that for the independence, there was no clear parts for the windows/pilot house, mainly due to the faceted plates on the model. This time however, clear PVC's are provided for the main pilot house windows on the freedom, and since the facets on the freedom isn't nearly as bad as the independence, the main deack house comes in a single piece. This should make assembly a snatch.Also, a simple deck house with very simple details is included to depic the pilot house consoles and chairs. But this is really simple and anyone who is serious could go and detail this up. But then again, don't think you can see much once the pilot house is locked down.

In fact, this deck house contain many many detailed parts to make it really good from an exterior point of view. A LOT, and I mean A LOT of smalls parts goes here, so do becareful and not launch some of these into another dimention! Behind the pilot deck is the helicopter hanger, and simple walls make this up. Again, detail this up if you want, but even with the hanger door open, it can be hardly seen. A MH-60 Seahawk and a RQ-8 Fire Scout is included. Strangely, the photo-etch tiedown rings from the Indepence is missing, although the "Pot holes" on the flight deck are still there. Freedom deck too small? The photo-etch safety nets are there though.

One pleaseant option that is included in this kit, and missing from the Independence is that two 30mm close in cannons (not Phalanx) turrets are included and can be placed up above the hanger deck directly behind the pilot house. These cannons are placed here to defend against small ships during surface combat. These are not offered for the Independence so if you want to equip your Independence kits with them, you can now. Or you can use the same blank covers and cover these areas up if that's your thing.

Anyways, a lot of small details in this kit so becareful. But it looks like Trumpeter did a great job on this ship like they did with the Independence (Although those thrice damned lock down rings gave me a headache, and it's still there, incomplete because of that reason lol). If you got the independence like me, well, you need this fella cause the Independence alone is not right, it's like going out with only one shoe on! So yeah, worth  the money, especially since I only paid $30 for mine! AS for the build, I'll keep you posted as soon as I get up the courage to finish the Independence! (Those thrice damned lock down rings! GRRRRRRRRRR.....)

 

On the Bench: Man, Choices, Choices...Where to start. But trying to close up shop on the Trumpeter F4F-3 (Early) Wildcat. On the Stash: Trumpeter's TBM-3 Avenger, Revell's C-17, Trumpeter's 1/32 Typhoon, Trumpeter's SBD-3 Dauntless, and waiting for my BR-86 to arrive In the "Spare Parts" Heap: Dragon's 1/32 P-51D Mustang Early Version (Worst kit I ever saw. Wasted $35 bucks! Ohh Well)!!!
JOIN OUR COMMUNITY!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

SEARCH FORUMS
FREE NEWSLETTER
By signing up you may also receive reader surveys and occasional special offers. We do not sell, rent or trade our email lists. View our Privacy Policy.