Styrene - no kit ought to intimidate you. At least no decent kit should. (I can think of some continental European plank-on-bulkhead ship kits that would intimidate me - because they're so lousy that making scale models from them would be almost impossible.) If you can build the armor models in those photos you can handle a Bluejacket schooner - and if you play the French horn you have the patience and determination necessary to complete any kit that's ever been produced.
I haven't actually examined the Bluejacket
Atlantic, but I'm confident that it's a well-designed kit and a sound basis for a nice scale model. I know it was updated fairly recently, with the addition, among other things, of a sheet of photo-etched metal parts. Bluejacket is one of three wood ship kit manufacturers (the others being Model Shipways and Caldercraft) whose kits I consistently recommend. Bluejacket hulls are well-known for being accurately carved from high-quality wood; my guess is that the hull would require a little carving to thin the bulwarks, but little else. The skills involved in building a solid-hull ship model are, in some cases, a little different than those of the plastic modeler, but in my opinion (though some wood ship modelers may regard this as heresy) neither form of modeling is inherently more difficult than the other.
I can offer one small tip about this particular ship, based on personal experience. Back in about 1981 or 1982 (I think), the remains of the
Atlantic were being scrapped by a ship repair firm, Metro Machine, in Norfolk, Viriginia. The Mariners' Museum in Newport News, where I was working at the time, got a phone call inviting us to look through what was left of the ship and save any artifacts we wanted.
We talked the shipyard into cutting the aftermost six feet or so off the stern for us. (The last time I was in Newport News it was on exhibit in the Small Craft Building.) I vividly remember the miserable, rainy winter day when my boss and I drove over to Norfolk with a flatbed truck behind us to pick the thing up. By the time we got there the remains of the
Atlantic amounted to a pile of lumber and a few miscellaneous pieces of metal. I rescued (with the boss's permission) a two-foot piece of deck planking, which is in my office in front of me as I'm typing this.
It's a pretty beat-up chunk of wood (the ship had spent some time on the bottom of the Elizabeth River before Metro scrapped her), but you don't have to study it for long to recognize that beneth the stains and crud is a beautiful piece of teak. One of these days I'm going to make a half-model of the ship out of it.
When we got back to the museum I looked up some on-board pictures of the
Atlantic in the hope of figuring out exactly what my souvenir was. I wasn't able to do that, but I did find some good shots of the deck planking. It was spectacular - and fastened down in a way I can't recall having seen elsewhere. The
Atlantic had a steel (or maybe it was iron) hull and deck beams, which had T cross-sections. The horizontal part of each beam had dozens of holes drilled through it. The deck planks were held to the beams by thousands of polished, round-headed brass screws, driven through those holes and into the planks
from below. She was, in other words, just about the only ship I've ever heard of with no externally-visible deck fastenings. To the modeler, that makes the job of accurately representing the deck remarkably simple.
I say - go for it. Bluejacket makes good merchandise, the
Atlantic was a beautiful ship, and she'd make an excellent "next step" after the
Rainbow. Good luck. It's a great hobby.