The Nautilus has a curious place in the history of plastic models. As Mr. Cooper noted, those three kits were originally released back in the fifties, before any accurate information about the real ship was made public. The kits were, in fact, based almost entirely on guesswork. As I remember, the Aurora designers - probably by pure luck - came a little closer to the truth than the others.
The Revell version was especially fictitious. (I'm basing this on Thomas Graham's terrific book, Remembering Revell Model Kits.) Based on some sketchy plans that had been published in Collier's magazine, it hit the shelves of the hobby shops in 1953, a few months before the real ship was launched. (The first issue, according to Dr. Graham, was in dark blue plasic, with a clear plastic observation bridge.) That made it the second Revell warship kit on the market (after the Missouri). In 1955 a second version of it added a Loon missile and a cylindrical hangar for it on the deck aft of the conning tower - despite the fact that the actual Nautilus never carried any such thing. The kit mercifully disappeared from the market for a long time, though it was one of the Revell/Monogram "Special Subjects" nostalgia reissues of the 1980s.
The Aurora Nautilus and Seawolf kits (which were virtually identical - and pretty awful) showed up in several different boxes during the fifties and sixties, if I remember right. I'd forgotten about the Lindberg one till I saw the photo in this thread.
It seems remarkable, in view of the ship's importance, that, since that rather bizarre burst of interest right before and after she was launched, the plastic kit industry has ignored her. The last I heard she'd been preserved as a museum ship at the Submarine Force Museum in New London. (I haven't been to that neck of the woods in quite a few years. Is she still there?) It seems like an accurate model of the Nautilus would be pretty popular - and nowadays there's surely no reason why the kit designers couldn't get it right. Such a kit would be historically significant, easy to build, and a great souvenir for folks who'd visited the ship. Trumpeter - are you listening?
Youth, talent, hard work, and enthusiasm are no match for old age and treachery.