Sorry to revive this thread (new here, just joined, I'm a long time plastic model kit fan/builder of all types in my late 40s).
I've been looking into which kits are the best to convert to POTC plastic model ships.
I currently have (unbuild) kits of most of the old plastic lindberg and heller model ships and when comparing them, in my opinion, the one that is most closest physically to the Black Pearl is the Heller "La Sirene" ship model. Especially the front and rear of the ships, the "sirene" figure is much like the woman in front of the Black Pearl.
The Lindberg "Captain Kidd" (Wappon Van Hamburg) kit is very close to it as well.
The Lindberg "Blackbeard" kit is very obviously the most like the Flying Dutchman as well.
I think that the POTC film people who drew up plans / drawings for these ships used these plastic model ships as inspiration. The "Blackbeard" (Soverign of the Seas) is so much like the Flying Dutchman as far as the hull goes and the front and rear portion of the ship matches (the sails not so much).
If you were to kitbash, those are the ones, as has been discussed in this thread, to work with.
I am going to do a crazy blasphemous (ha, ha) experiment and (since these are purely fantasy ship from POTC) I am going to take all the parts needed from the megablocks toy kits of the Black Pearl and Flying Dutchman and after puttying and glueing the seams, etc, changing the fake looking masts and decks with those from the Lindberg ships.
These Megablocks toys are very close to the movie versions, and the amount of detail is great for the odd parts. Why reinvent the wheel? Especially since these are fantasy ships that don't exist outside the movies. The front and back parts of the ships especially are already there for the taking in plastic and very close to scale to the Lindberg ships (which are inaccurate anyways).
If you want to do that, Amazon.com has a crazy sale where you can get the huge megablocks set that combines the Black Pearl and Flying Dutchman together in one box for a fraction of the price of getting them seperate! It was like 1/4 of the price! I think they made a mistake in the price, but I ordered it and was really pleased at how great the parts looked in comparison to the movie versions of the ships.
Any opinions? thanks