I have the Glencoe NS Savannah kit and have been wanting to build it for sometime, even though it may not be the best representation "out of the box", at least compared to the Revell kit. When I bought this kit, the Revell kit had not been reissued yet, and I had no references on the quality of the Glencoe kit when I bought it (those were my pre-forum days). I considered buying the Revell kit and putting the Glencoe kit back in the closet but hey, why waste a good kit, and who doesn't love a challenge?! Could it be any worse than the Lindberg Blue Devil destroyer that I've heard so much about?
I saw an old post from Duke Maddog from 2005 with a photo of his built up Glencoe kit, and he did a great job. I think with a little nip and tuck here and there, I can fix some of the kit's inherent inaccuracies. I have to work on the bridge structure first, then get the molded-on deck planking off. I like the 1/350 scale, and I have to say that the plastic is very thick and somewhat sturdy. The biggest challenge overall will be to eliminate it's toy-like appearance.
I'd like to solicit any input from builders of this kit or the Revell SAVANNAH, and any photos you may have of your builds. I'm trolling for photo references of both the real ship and any built-up models. The Merchant Marine museum at Kings Point has a great model in 1/96 scale, I think I'll go out there and snap a few photos at some point.
PS - I delivered the completed Trumpeter USS COLUMBUS to my father last weekend for his 80th birthday. A note for JTilley if you read this: he was speechless at first, but later that night he gave me a complete chronology of his stint in the Navy, most of which I never knew. He smiled the whole time. The most surprising revelation was that he wanted to learn how to be a baker while in the Navy, but ended up in damage control/firefighting instead!