haha welcome to the forums- first off let me say I loved the title of your post!
Make sure to stop back in and let us know how the rocket turns out, best of luck at getting that straight line!
-was the problem getting the tape straight or the paint getting under the tape? I've found that not all "masking" tapes are the same, sometimes even painter's tape has a problem with paint seepage, I guess it depends on the plastics and paints involved and how well one can really stick it down...