Hey Kevin, you may want to consider 5 minute epoxy. For me, super glue just sets up too fast., and it's hard to get any excess off. But with 5 minute epoxy, it takes some time to set up, and when it is just past tacky, you can pick off any excess with a toothpick or your knife, leaving behind almost nothing. And it's very strong too.
Whatever works for you, best wishes!