@EdGrune
Yeah, I think I may be on the verge of a major disaster if I don't get this right.
I tried the dip-in-dry-paint-and-apply-lightly technique on a piece of paper. You're right, it either didn't have an effect or, when I pressed harder, started to come out splotchy. So that's out.
Eaglecash867 is right in that I should just airbrush it on, very very lightly. The problem is when I do airbrush on a low setting, the paint alternates between coming out finely or spurting out. So that's also out of the picture.
I'm not sure why my airbrush does that (too cheap?), or if it's truly the low-pressure that's causing it. When I watch those Sideshow Collectible videos on YouTube, they add very fine shadows to the figurines in that way (with the airbrush pressure set to verrrry low). Maybe it's coz my airbrush is a siphon airbrush that I can't do the same? I'm definitely not understanding something here...
Someday I'll have to figure it out. For now, though, I think I'm just gonna cash in my chips and complete the model without the effect. Live to fight another day. Or whatever other metaphor you can think of. This is the closest I've come to completing a model for quite a while, and I do think I'm on the brink of something display-worthy (which would make it only my second display-worthy model), so I'm being very careful how I proceed with what's left.
Into model building since September 2019. Also into books (mostly science-fiction), comic books, and gaming.