I use Tamiya tape with success.
I have an old piece of glass (from a cheap photo frame) that i stick a lenth of tape too. Then i use a metal ruler and a brand new No.11 blade to cut a lenght of tape to the desired width. I read about this method on another website years ago (I think it was Swanny's tips on how to mask canopies or something similar).
Using this method enables you to cut tape to any desired width and the glass backing enables the blade to cut through easily and also, the tape to lift up without losing too much adhesion.
Also, DoogsATX is quite right with having momentum when taping. Whenever i'm taping, i hold the end of the tape and look to where it should finish, pull it taught and then lay it down. Following this, i then burnish down.
However, it will be a bit mor tedious and difficult with a conical surface like the prop of the Mustang, but it can still be down, just requires patience and practice.
Chris.