- Member since
November 2005
|
Posted by Anonymous
on Monday, February 2, 2004 10:41 AM
QUOTE: Originally posted by styrene
While acrylics can be water-based, their carrier solvents such as the alcohols, are quite flammable. [snip]
OK, rant's over. Feel free to flame away......
Gip Winecoff
|
|
Um, that was a pun right?
Just out of curiousity, when the fumes cause flames, what are we taking about here, a Hollywood-grade explosion?
Or can you get away with an extinquisher nearby?
|
- Member since
May 2003
- From: The flat lands of the Southeast
|
Posted by styrene
on Monday, February 2, 2004 10:55 AM
ngc7293,
Wow. Good pick up. Had no idea there was a pun there.
Actually, it can be anything from a small fire that can be effectively extinguished with a small fire extinguisher, to a rather large conflagration/explosion depending on what you're using, how long you're using it, the type of fan in use, and a lot of other variables. Obviously, airbrushing an acrylic camo job on your 1/72 Floxnard is going to be a little less risky than spraying a lacquer rattle can onto your 1/196 USS Graxflop. In either case, however, a good extinguisher close by is a good idea.
Gip Winecoff
1882: "God is dead"--F. Nietzsche
1900: "Nietzsche is dead"--God
|
- Member since
November 2005
|
Posted by Anonymous
on Monday, February 2, 2004 11:14 AM
As the one who originally posted about the cardboard box idea, I agree - all due caution should be taken to understand the materials you're using. Simply put, don't spray flammable materials into a potential ignition source.
That said, I've tested my own solvents (windex, water) by spraying into an open flame (propane torch). Neither is an issue. My own acrylic paints behave similarly. I couldn't even get methyl-alcohol based windshield wiper fluid to ignite, though I don't use it to thin, only for cleaning in a little cleaning tub (never sprayed). I will never shoot flammable solvents through this particular booth. In all likelihood, I will never shoot such products, ever, as I just don't have the need to do so. Those who do, or may do so in the future, be sure your booth is doesn't present an ignition source.
If you're at all unsure, either test it out carefully before proceeding, or don't do it at all. Use some common sense.
As to the insurance issue, insurance is precisely intended to cover those things that one fails to predict. Unless specifically excluded in the policy, the general nature of renters/homeowners policies is that accidents will be covered. Insurance routinely pays for things that are the "fault" of some person's incompetence or negligence. One could well argue that it is one of main purposes for having insurance at all! Of course, I am absolutely *not* advocating actually being incompetent or negligent just because somebody might be there to cover your rear.
|
- Member since
May 2003
- From: The flat lands of the Southeast
|
Posted by styrene
on Monday, February 2, 2004 11:45 AM
limd21
Glad to know you've thought it out, and your points are well taken. And you're right: Common sense goes a long way.
I just have one question out of my own curiosity:
How did you know that the methanol mixture didn't flash/ignite/burn since the flame would be invisible?
Gip Winecoff
1882: "God is dead"--F. Nietzsche
1900: "Nietzsche is dead"--God
|
- Member since
November 2005
|
Posted by Anonymous
on Monday, February 2, 2004 3:32 PM
QUOTE: Originally posted by styrene
limd21
I just have one question out of my own curiosity:
How did you know that the methanol mixture didn't flash/ignite/burn since the flame would be invisible?
|
|
Great point. I'll need to recheck this (under safely controlled conditions, of course ! It may have been luck or it might have been that the particular bottle of WW fluid that I have has abnormally low concentration of methanol. Or it could've been the fact that the ambient temp when I tried this was in the low 20's, making ignition a bit more difficult. I've been around car racing circles and methanol fires are one area where I've some rudimentary safety training, and I didn't notice the telltale heat "shimmer". In any case, I don't advocate spraying an alcohol solution at an ignition source.
|
- Member since
April 2003
- From: Hayward, CA
|
Posted by MikeV
on Monday, February 2, 2004 7:50 PM
Good points Gip.
I may build a simple booth as was mentioned for acrylics and use the Comair/Rotron 10" fan that I bought off Ebay several months back.
It is this model here and it is a brushless motor so I am hoping that would eliminate any potential of igniting isopropyl alcohol.
This fan is rated at 550 cfm by the way which is pretty impressive for a 10" fan.
If I need to spray enamels or lacquers then I will do as I do now and wear my Comfo Elite dual-cartridge respirator and open the side door of the garage and spray that direction. It's a pain to paint this way but I have no other choice as I don't own this house and can't go cutting a hole in the wall for a spray booth vent.
Mike
“Wisdom is the right use of knowledge. To know is not
to be wise. Many men know a great deal, and are all the greater fools
for it. There is no fool so great a fool as a knowing fool. But to know
how to use knowledge is to have wisdom. " Charles Spurgeon
|
- Member since
November 2005
|
Posted by Anonymous
on Tuesday, February 3, 2004 3:24 AM
Only a suggestion to prevent a fire...
Build a filteration system in between the fan and the booth. It could be a wall of cotton or an element such as the automotive air filter. That should trap the excess paint and preventing it from reacing the motor thus preventing fire.
Just a thought from a non-technical man
|
- Member since
November 2005
|
Posted by Anonymous
on Tuesday, February 3, 2004 10:18 AM
The filter won't help if the vapors from the paint carrier are flammable. I.e. an organic solvent based lacquer. The filter may trap all the solid/liquid paint, but it won't trap the vapors, which are still flammable.
BTW, I did some more checking of the flammability of windshield fluid. All of this was done on my concrete driveway, so as not to burn my garage down if something went awry. I soaked a sheet of newspaper in the fluid and tried to ignite it with a propane torch, nothing. I then filled a little spray bottle with some fluid and sprayed a cloud of fluid in the air - still nothing. So, though the stuff *is* combustible, it's pretty darn hard to light off.
Some online searching found some key data. Windshield fluid (33% methanol) has a flash point of 98degF. I.e. the liquid would need to be at 98degF to form an ignitable mixture with air. In contrast, 100% methanol has a flash point of just 55degF. (Flash point goes up as the water percentage increases). FWIW, lacquer thinnner has a flash point of 42degF, acetone -4degF, and gasoline has a flash point of -40deg (which is good for those of us who need to drive in cold climates!)
Again, be CAREFUL!
|
More great sites from Kalmbach Media
|
|