Don, I ran into that also.
Run a layer of clear tape around the bottle of paint when you get it. Both for grip and to help keep the labeling in case of thinner hitting the label.
Then, instead of straps or pliers,,,,,open the bottles with gloves with rough rubber grip palm/finger areas. Those work just exactly like those rubber discs intended to open jars in the kitchen.
Run either Vaseline or Chap Stick on your threads, and you don't get stuck lids with that jar of paint again. Put that on the bottle's threads, not the cap's. If you have old bottles with paint dried on the threads already, put wine corks in the bottles so you can have the bottle sealed while it lays on its side, allowing you to scrub the threads clean before you lube them.
Switch to the cone type of Phenolic lids,(exhaling into the jar),,,,,and you never get a dried out paint again.
Rex