I can't think of much beyond what the others have suggested. 1. Possible that the paint could be old, or you're using a thinner not fully compatible with that paint. 2. Possible the thinning ratio is not ideal, some paints really do better when thinned a great deal. I've sometimes thinned Model Master Enamel as much as 1:1 for a 50% thinner mix.
I'd recommend maybe trying some scrap plastic sheet, or shiny printed cardboard box material, like store purchases are sold in. Experimenting on that with thinning ratios, pressures and distances can prevent mistakes on the model. Finally, maybe a fresh paint supply from the hobby shop will get this sorted. Best of luck with a fix. Please let us know how you make out.
Patrick