I'm kind of at a loss, trying to think of what the problems could be related to. It appears contamination of the paint in the bottles seems unlikely, as you've tried multiple bottles with the same results. Next would be possible contamination of the agents you use as reducers, but again that seems not a strong suspect.
I guess it takes me back to the airbrush, so let's think it through. If the airbrush worked well to start and produced good results, now has problems, then it's a good starting point for ruling out the paint.
The airbrush might have had an o-ring or washer get damaged along the way, so when you try to spray do you see any bubbles come up in the bottle or cup? If a nozzle is not seated well, then it can also lead to improper spray consistency. Not to be insulting, but are you quite sure the AB has been fully and carefully cleaned at the completion of every job you've done with it? A stray bit of dried paint, cotton bud residue or anything else can raise heck with an AB's function.
Did you take a good look through Don's Airbrush website? Your airbrush is one of the examples used, and there is a great section on cleaning of the AB.
Above all, don't be discouraged and bail out, this is a quality AB, whatever kind of tummy ache it's experiencing CAN and WILL be resolved, just a matter of sticking with it.
I had a Paasche VL for years, worked well but I hated the two part trigger when it came time to re-install it after teardown. Paasche had a replacement one part trigger, it required a different air valve. I bought both, installed them and the AB would not work. I fought it for some time, gave up and sent it back to Paasche for repair.
I had left a tiny o-ring behind in the air valve port, fault was mine, but my frustration was easily resolved by just having that mistake fixed. Loved the old VL after that, but for the time it didn't work I hated it. Stick with it, you'll get there. Let us know what you find.
Lastly, tearing down and re-assembling an AB a few times will teach you a lot, about fit and function of an airbrush. Familiarity is a real key to using and maintaining an AB, try that and you may find something that is just not fully adjusted or fitting properly.
Best of luck with it.
Patrick