Hi Everyone,
Thanks for the suggestions. I am trying to achieve the following look:
Basically, I want the Bare Metal foil to look like an old, oxodized aluminum light pole. I achieved the appearance of aluminum grain by rubbing the foil with steel wool. I think the grain looks real natural, but the foil is just too shinny.
I tried some tests using a plastic spoon with foil. Painting it with flat cleat paint made the foil look like it was painted with grey paint. All of the grain disappeared. I tried bleach, the purple stuff and Simple Greeen. None of that worked. Next I'll try vinegar and oven cleaner (the stuff with lye in it). If none of that works I'll just leave the foil shinny.