Matt B
The scratches begin almost at the start of the tapering of the needle and go the entire length. It happened as I was working the needle back and forth in hopes of getting it to loosen up. I stopped doing it as soon as I saw what was happening. It was carving a groove into it about milimeter wide.
Matt - the scratches running the full length of the needle, tell me the fit problem is at the back. Sounds like the the damage is done when the needle is withdrawn, at this point I would recommend return to Badger, or the seller if they will accept it and handle it.
I bought a new Badger 200G, and inserting the needle felt quite rough from the start, there was lot's of drag both directions. I had plenty of new parts in my spares box, replacing the back two parts that screw into the handle fixed it 100%.
Now it should be Badger that unwinds this problem, and they certainly will. Don't give up on it, once sorted it will serve you well.
Best of luck.
Patrick