The blue bottle is MicroSet which should be less aggressive than the red (MicroSol). It should also be thin and watery. The blue bottle smells vinegary, whereas the red bottle has a very slight ammonia-like smell. I've not known MicroSet to be thick at all.
Though you can't really rule it out, it's unlikely to be an age related issue, as the bottle of MicroSet that I have is at least 25 years old and still works fine.
MicroSet doesn't usually leave any noticeable residue. On the other hand, MicroSol has been known to sometimes cause hazing on acrylic finishes (including Future) particularly if the base has not had sufficient curing time (as opposed to drying time). Normally, when this happens, an overspray with a clear glosscoat will eliminate the hazing.