Personally, I do think of the Black Pearl and the Peter Pan ship as nautical nonsense. However, any new plastic sailing ship kit is cause for celebration among those of us who build them because it shows that the industry has a little life. If those kits can attract kids to build them, they might grow into serious sailing ship modellers and more kits might be manufactured.
I still believe that there is a market for plastic sailing ship kits. Again, just witness that for the HECEPOB kits that are far more expensive and (sometimes) "nautical nonsense." If only the manufacturers would do some serious market research!
Bill