I do not have the kit in person, but have some remarks based on the photos I have seen.
Trumpy screwed the pooch on the 5 inchers. They are simplified and out of proportion. They appear to be scaled up versions of the skywave pieces.
The 1.1s look decent but could benefit from some AM PE or L'Arsenal resin replacements.
The 20s match Tamiya for quality.
BIG plus are the one-piece turrets and the open bridge windows. Rafts, though not as detailed as some, actually capture the "feel" of these parts better than most kits IMHO. Funnel detail is good. Open searchlight tower lattice is a nice touch, though it will probably be replaced by most. Planking is excellent.
Searchlights, directors and small fittings look OK. Splinter shields are average, nothing to write home about. Cats and Cranes are only Ok, basically the sames as the North Carolina kit. Painting calls for MS12 when she carried MS21 (IIRC). Can't comment on accuracy. Surface detail is about Tamiya quality and you sure can't beat the price. Overall, about on par with the North Carolina and Essex kits, but better engineered and with some big improvments, but some shortcomings (5 inchers) of its own. Looks like it will build nice OOB and with some new 5" and 1.1 guns and a good PE set it will be a show stopper. And a very good value for the money.