SEARCH FINESCALE.COM

Enter keywords or a search phrase below:

1/72 MINIATURAS ALEMANY - "Tiger Maintenance Group" (Img and review)

2091 views
2 replies
1 rating 2 rating 3 rating 4 rating 5 rating
  • Member since
    April 2006
  • From: Romania
Posted by Panzer_Grenadire on Friday, December 14, 2007 4:25 PM

Thanks a lot Doog, and you are right, it has a lot of potential, something like a variant of the more famous Preiser, but in white metal. I have to adit that I am a great fan of Preiser sets, but these figures match perfect with those from Preiser sets.

I bought some Preiser sets when I was in the US, from Michigan Toy Store, one of the best shops I have visited. They had a lot of things of my interest there. In addition, my uncle came in Romania in autumn and I asked him to buy from there several sets from Warriors, CMK and FOV.  

I can say that I was impressed by the Warriors  figures, they look very, very nice.

I really do not know if Miniaturas Alemany products are available in the USA, I bought mine from Romania, a friend of mine who has a model shop imported them for me from Spain. I bought all their sets with figures as well as several kits that include figures.

I really have a lot of sets to review, time is my problem, but I think all of us have the same problem.

Once again, thank you very much and I must tell you that at present I am working at something I am sure you will enjoy, they ride....

 Cristian Florescu

  • Member since
    January 2007
Posted by the doog on Thursday, December 13, 2007 11:15 PM

Another superb review once again, PG!

This looks like a kit with a ton of potential and fun! It's practically a "diorama in a box"!

Nice job painting these little men! I don't even know if these are available in the USA yet though; I haven't heard of them yet. We have a hard enough time getting Presier stuff here!

Thanks again for a great review!  

  • Member since
    April 2006
  • From: Romania
1/72 MINIATURAS ALEMANY - "Tiger Maintenance Group" (Img and review)
Posted by Panzer_Grenadire on Thursday, December 13, 2007 8:22 AM

This is another pretty different set, I suppose a quite interesting one and I worked it in parallel with CMK's Germans for Famo. 

With this occasion I tried to depict and detail how much I could different types of "Y" straps and suspenders. The "Y" straps are copying the black leather, tropical types and you will see even one in camouflage (there were such models, field conversion). In addition, to several straps I put a brown reinforce and at the figure with helmet I painted the back side of the straps with brown and tehe front with black. I do not know if appears very clear in the pictures, it is a very small detail. The suspenders with breided ends are painted with white and light green, as they were met in most cases. At the camouflage trousers I tried to depict two versions of Wehrmacht camo.

As I said and inside the review, my set missed the bare head which I replaced with a Preiser one looking pretty close with the one appearing on the artwork opf the box. It is the only add that I did to this set, I wanted to show the set like it is.

Thank you for looking and any comments or remarks on the review or images are very welcome.

Cristian Florescu     

 

MINIATURES ALEMANY 1/72

"Tiger Maintenance Group"

Manufacturer

Miniaturas Alemany

Scale

1/72

Set Code

FG 7217

Year

?

No. of Figures

11

No. of Poses

11

Aspect

Medium/Tall

Material

White Metal

Optimal Period

1939 -1945

 

Review 

The sets made of white metal represent a reliable solution for improving 1/72 WWII German Army figure collections with some very interesting poses, the majority of them pretty uncommon. There are more companies working with this material and one, which has a large range related to WWII German Army is Minatures Alemany.

Except regular sets with figures, this producer has also a rich assortment of kits including not only a vehicle or a gun, but also several extremely interesting figures. Unfortunately, probably due to commercial purposes, with few exceptions, the poses incorporated in such a kit are not duplicated in sets referred only to figures.

As title emphasizes, this set tries grabbing the attention of the great number of Tiger fans, which is one of the most popular vehicle in the scale, present in almost all collections of German ground vehicles admirers.

On the other hand, almost all representative manufacturers like Revell, Dragon and Trumpeter rushed to launch on the market at least a version of this famous vehicle, being probably one of the most produced Panzer in the scale. Such things imply a large target group for a set dedicated to soldiers working around it, being also known the fact that Tigers were some of the most exposed tanks to maintenance due to their often breakdowns, so plenty of diorama options here, the reference materials abounding in this regard.

Furthermore, the included poses not only are addressed to somebody who has such a tank, but also to persons needing to cover topics such as maintenance for various vehicles, crews for 88 guns and the list may endless continue.    

Maintenance represents a quite attractive subject, especially for non-combat diorama fans, but it is good to know that some of the figures presented here may take part in combat as gunners or crew of a vehicle in the middle of a battle.

Likewise, in spite of the existence of several dedicated sets or even kits including figures suitable for maintenance activities, released by different manufacturers like Preiser, CMK, Revell, or Miniaturas Alemany which has a wide range in the field, all of these are far enough for covering the huge request  on the matter.

Another interesting and nice issue recognized at figures enclosed in sets addressed to maintenance, due to their cloths similitude, these are in most of the cases suitable not only for vehicles, but also may be enrolled in Luftwaffe or Kriegsmarine for carrying out similar activities, so plenty of options are provided by such a set.

Though first impression when reading "metal" goes to something tough, white metal is quite fragile, not like resin, but still breakable and for this reason Miniaturas Alemany delivers most of their sets in two boxes, one having sponge as protective layers. The artwork of the box illustrates the painted version of the figures contained inside it. This is a good approach for several reasons, in this way the artwork serves both as assembly guide and painting instructions. If the last mentioned one has not a paramount importance, the assembly instructions may sometimes be quite necessary. Even if in general the figures come on a short sprue, comprising the body and the parts, there were several cases, in different sets, when a piece is really missing from the box. Fortunately, the problem has a basic solution, the missing piece can be replaced with a Preiser one. Furthermore, hard plastic and white metal response extremely good to superglue gel which fix them in an extremely strong bond. For such cases the artwork is very important, showing us how the absent element should appear, but this is necessary only if it intended to preserve the sculptor's intention. For instance, inside my box which will be bellow presented, it was missing the bare head, which of course, I replaced with a Preiser looking pretty close to the one appearing in the artwork. Regardless such inconvenient, the sets from this manufacturer have a great valor, filling important gaps in the scale, offering a lot of opportunities for conversions and enrich any figure collection with interesting components.  

The maintenance group for Tiger proposed to us by this Spanish manufacturer is formed by eleven figures dressed in diverse ways, adapted for the implemented activity. Moreover, the set also contains three accessories for them, respectively one barrel, and two 88 mm ammo boxes.

With the exception of a figure who keeps his M36 tunic unbuttoned and one wearing a mesh T-shirt, the rest of figures are dressed in various types of shirts, the M43 model, easily recognized after the pleats on the pockets, being worn by a single trooper.

Also there are featured two types of trousers, the regular one-not so well detailed in order to be established the type, as well as another model that could be represented as tank or assault gun pants, camouflage over pants or service trousers. Besides, all figures with regular trousers have long marching boots while those with the other model of pants shoe ankle boots.

Most of the soldiers possess the M43 cap, but there is one with steel helmet, two with M34 overseas cap and another wearing nothing on his head.

No personal gear or weapons are presented on these figures, with the exception of the suspenders with braided ends or the famous "Y" straps. A single figure dressed in shirt did not receive either straps or suspenders. In fact, the set offers the great opportunity to its owner to paint these uniform accessories in different colours. Nevertheless, if it is taken the decision to paint the suspenders as "Y" straps, in such cases it is advisable to remove the braided ends appearing on several figures or not to paint them in the specific colour.

In addition, perhaps from moulding, a couple of figures seem to wear gloves and their palms may be painted in this way, fact which corresponds with the reality, maintenance personnel often using gloves for a better protection.

Taking into account their cloths, the set definitely addresses to warm periods, and if the correct pants are painted in camouflage schemes, both Waffen SS and Wehrmacht are possible.

The poses in the group were not designed for carrying out repairing activities, they look like being caught in preparing the tank for battle, refilling it with ammo, petroleum and even a painting action.

Except one crouching figure, the rest are standing and most of figures hold a related object in their hands, in fact the needing items for a tank. Just two figures have nothing in their hands, and for being more precisely, it should be said that one of them was designed to roll the spare barrel.

As it is normal, the thing that a tank consumed the most, if the crew had the luck to survive more hours on the battle field was the ammunition, and in this regard there are given four figures holding 88 mm projectiles and another one pushing a similar ammo box. These figures are extremely suitable as crew for the 88 mm Flak gun, well spread in the scale especially thanks to Hasegawa, but coming with some ugly servants or ACE Pak 43/41 which is offered without any servant.

The projectile holders are nice poses, keeping the ammo in a quite natural manner and we have here the occasion to paint their ends in the appropriate colors for showing which type of projectile is, black for armor piercing, yellow for defrag and white for heat. The Tiger tanks had some machineguns, so a special pose was created for bringing the necessary ammo. It is the figure dressed in T-shirt with helmet and around his neck he has a MG ammo belt. Moreover, this pose is interesting due to the way he wears his suspenders, flowing around his hips.  

The refilling with petroleum and oil is ensured by three figures, including here and the one who rolls the barrel. They carry their items quite fine, but maybe a little strange is the one with the gas container, namely the way he holds it with the opening down. Judging him after his pose, it could be assessed that either the container is empty or he is lifting it in order to fix it on the vehicle. Both the roller and the one with the pail are extremely nice figures, in interesting poses which are rarely encountered in the scale.

Probably the most exciting figure of the set is the "artist" who is right in the middle of painting the vehicle. It is a hardly ever seen pose in the scale, but a more than useful one, implementing an activity very often done by Germans. It is well known that especially in the late part of war, Germans were painting or changing the camouflage schemes and even the color of their vehicles according to the environment or season, and it is Minaturas Alemany great merit to bring us such a soldier.

The last figure, with nothing in his hands can be put to do a lot of jobs, separately or in connection with his comrades, as an assistant for the one who rolls the barrel, some tasks with the spare ammo boxes or preparing to give a helpful hand for loading the ammo inside the vehicle.

As it was earlier emphasized, the soldiers may be used not only in other purposes, but also in other armies like Luftwaffe or Kriegsmarine. Another good and imperative role at least for a part of them is as crew members for the opened top vehicles carrying 88 mm guns, like Nashorns, these figures fitting very well in the fighting compartment of such a vehicle.

Regarding the accuracy of the uniforms, these are well done, but sculpture and molding are not astonishing, although more than acceptable. Several small details, like buttons, are easily seen as well as an infrequent in scale left shoulder board found on the M36 tunic, which is unbuttoned and hangs down.

Definitely, the suspenders with braided ends are one of the attractions of the set, such items do not appear so frequent at 1/72 and the ones here included are excellent.  

When it comes to the anatomy of these soldiers, it must be stressed that on the one hand, there are several differences between the sizes of some figures, but on the other hand the variation is extremely small and borders in the normal limits of human beings.

Likewise, facial expressions are fair and there are several alternations between fine palms or fingers with some not so well detailed.

Thanks to multi-part approach, excess of plastic was avoided, but flash is more than present on each figure and in spite of being metal flash, removing it is unproblematic.

A really and truly operation of paramount importance is to primer with adequate substances these figures before painting with enamel. If it is not done, than the painting effort will be ruined, the paint will be taken away after several touches. Tamya primer for metal provides fair results and for better sealing, it can be used matt varnish after the painting process is finalized.

Several soldiers require assembly and super glue gel gives great results. Furthermore, it is good to keep in mind that the same glue gives amazing results for fixing white metal with hard plastic parts. This thing opens the gates for endless conversions and improvements, Preiser body parts, gear or weapons being greatly recommended for using in this regard, especially due to the fact that Preiser and Miniaturas Alemany figures have almost the same size.       

All troopers miss bases, thing that pleases the diorama fans which are absolved from removing them, but may annoy the wargamers which in general prefer soldiers with bases.  

As it was mentioned before, there are several sets or kits with similar soldiers coming from other manufacturers and the present maintenance group fits extremely good from the point of view of size, uniform and gear with those included in Preiser's "German Air and Ground Crew" and "German Tank Crew" (fitting perfect), CMK's "German Mechanics", "German Armourers for Tiger I" or even Revell's "German Navy" (a little bit taller). To all these should be added as well as figures from kits like "88 mm Flak 36/37 with crew" or "Panzer 38 (T) with German Mechanic Team", also released by Miniaturas Alemany.

Through its multiple uses and interesting poses, the "Tiger Maintenance Group" is a set that can capture the attention of all 1/72 German Army diorama builders, collectors or wargamers. Furthermore, even if when opening the box, the first impression may not have a powerful impact, after painting them, these soldiers disclose a really nice appearance. Lastly, the conversion alternatives, both with pieces from the same manufacturer or with Preiser parts should be taken into consideration, representing a reliable alternative for enriching the number of figures in any collection.     

Historical Accuracy

9

Anatomy

8

Poses Quality

9

Details Quality

8

Mould Quality

8

Sculpture

8

Recommendation/Utility

9

TOTAL

8

 

 

 

JOIN OUR COMMUNITY!

Our community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.

SEARCH FORUMS
FREE NEWSLETTER
By signing up you may also receive reader surveys and occasional special offers. We do not sell, rent or trade our email lists. View our Privacy Policy.