WW1 Ships we'd all like to see!!

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Friday, March 27, 2009 7:23 PM

Yes, you are absolutely right, the Von der Tann is a most excellent ship, and the destroyers and torpedo boats must not be forgotten!

Reply

steviec

Member since
March 2009

Posted by steviec on Friday, March 27, 2009 6:31 PM

absolutly Von der Tann and numerous destroyerrs

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Tuesday, March 24, 2009 11:30 AM

De nada.... You can probably pick up a cheap Koenig, Markgraf, or Grosser Kurfurst over on Ebay for cheap money (pretty good kit too!)

Reply

starduster

Member since
February 2006
From: portland oregon area

Posted by starduster on Tuesday, March 24, 2009 8:48 AM

Searat12, I didn't know that thanks. Karl

photograph what intrests you today.....because tomorrow it may not exist.

Reply

Lufbery

Member since
December 2002
From: Harrisburg, PA

Posted by Lufbery on Sunday, March 22, 2009 12:19 PM

searat12 wrote:
Lufbery wrote:

Ah well. Excuse me for cluttering your thread with an enthusiastic response.
Had I know your priorities, I would never have suggested such a lowly and insignificant subject for a model.
We benighted ones need to be kept in line.
My apologies, I was grumpy and out of line!

No problem.

Regards,

-Drew

Build what you like; like what you build.

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Sunday, March 22, 2009 11:08 AM

starduster wrote:

   I have a few names to add to pre ww 1 ships and some ww 1 ships, 1/72 scale would be nice.   Karl
Pre WW1
Agamemnon British
Gloire          British
Warrior        British

Napoleon     France
WW 1
Redoutable France
HMS Devastation British, first ocean going battleship without sails.
SMS koning Germany
SMS Grosser Kurfurst Germany

Some good stuff here, but did you know you can already get the SMS Koenig and Grosser Kurfurst in 1/350? ICM makes them and they are available for about $40-$50 a pop....

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Sunday, March 22, 2009 11:06 AM

Lufbery wrote:

Ah well. Excuse me for cluttering your thread with an enthusiastic response.
Had I know your priorities, I would never have suggested such a lowly and insignificant subject for a model.
We benighted ones need to be kept in line.

My apologies, I was grumpy and out of line!

Reply

starduster

Member since
February 2006
From: portland oregon area

Posted by starduster on Sunday, March 22, 2009 2:59 AM

I have a few names to add to pre ww 1 ships and some ww 1 ships, 1/72 scale would be nice. Karl

Pre WW1

Agamemnon British

Gloire British

Warrior British

Napoleon France

WW 1

Redoutable France

HMS Devastation British, first ocean going battleship without sails.

SMS koning Germany

SMS Grosser Kurfurst Germany

photograph what intrests you today.....because tomorrow it may not exist.

Reply

Lufbery

Member since
December 2002
From: Harrisburg, PA

Posted by Lufbery on Sunday, March 22, 2009 12:47 AM

Ah well. Excuse me for cluttering your thread with an enthusiastic response.

Had I know your priorities, I would never have suggested such a lowly and insignificant subject for a model.

We benighted ones need to be kept in line.

-Drew

Build what you like; like what you build.

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Saturday, March 21, 2009 9:23 PM

I get this in almost every thread I start... Yes, Engadine would be of interest EVENTUALLY.... But there are so many more truly SIGNIICANT ships that really deserve priority first!! HMS Engadine was a coverted FERRY fer chrissakes, and did next to nothing in the whole war... If you are big on aviation, why wouldn't we want to see something like a HMS Renown with a launching platform off the turrets, or HMS Furious with a launching platform and an 18" gun aft FIRST? It is all about priorities here! Keep it simple, keep it clear for the model manufacturers!

Reply

Lufbery

Member since
December 2002
From: Harrisburg, PA

Posted by Lufbery on Saturday, March 21, 2009 8:44 PM

searat12 wrote:
Well.... I gotta say there are a heckuva lot of other ships i would like to see before the HMS Engadine (HMS Furious, for instance!!)!! What about HMS Tiger? What about SMS Von Der Tann?? What about a few destroyers????

Seriously? What do you have against Engadine? Personally, I think the origins of naval aviation are fascinating -- especially when one of the subjects was involved in the largest naval battle of the Great War.

That's not to say that Furious or Lion or Queen Mary wouldn't make great models.

Regards,

-Drew

Build what you like; like what you build.

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Saturday, March 21, 2009 8:02 PM

Well.... I gotta say there are a heckuva lot of other ships i would like to see before the HMS Engadine (HMS Furious, for instance!!)!! What about HMS Tiger? What about SMS Von Der Tann?? What about a few destroyers????

Reply

Lufbery

Member since
December 2002
From: Harrisburg, PA

Posted by Lufbery on Saturday, March 21, 2009 4:56 PM

I'd love to see the HMS Engadine. A display with a 1/72 scale Short 184 seaplane and a 1/350 or 1/720 (or 1/700) HMS Engadine would be a great way to capture a piece of WWI Battle of Jutland history.

Regards,

-Drew

Build what you like; like what you build.

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Saturday, March 21, 2009 3:14 PM

BB35 USS Texas, might actually be a good suggestion for the 'Practical Models' thread too....

Reply

deattilio

Member since
October 2005
From: New Port Richey

Posted by deattilio on Saturday, March 21, 2009 1:45 PM

Someone really should start fill this massive hole in ship models, along with the pre-WW I stuff. Though there is a slew of these ships on my "wish there were" list, I limit my post to the one at the top of the list:

BB-35 U.S.S. Texas

WIP:
Trying to get my hobby stuff sorted - just moved and still unpacking.

"Gator, Green Catskill....Charlie On Time"

Reply

u-boater

Member since
November 2007
From: North Carolina

Posted by u-boater on Thursday, March 19, 2009 8:25 AM

Great selections!!

Though personally,I'd like to see the submarines produced in 1/72 scale.

www.resinilluminati.com

Reply

surfsup

Member since
March 2009
From: brisbane australia

Posted by surfsup on Wednesday, March 18, 2009 4:54 AM

What about the following:-

An Indefatigable class Battlecruiser

HMS Royal Oak

SMS Pommern

SMS Schleswig-Holstein

HMS Agincourt

HIJMS Kongo

Just a few more to ponder over. Except for a personal favourite HMAS Sydney.

If i was your wife, i'd poison your tea! If Iwas your husband, I would drink it! WINSTON CHURCHILL

Reply

mic53mlb

Member since
March 2008
From: West Palm Beach, Florida

Posted by mic53mlb on Tuesday, March 17, 2009 11:56 PM

The Viribus Unitis if only. What an ubelievable ship design to ask for !! Again here we go... WWI ships again to be released !! You need to go to this site www.viribusunitus.ca and check it out. Any problems let me know. What a georgeous ship only three of them and two in existence ..... break out the dive gear.

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

Posted by searat12 on Tuesday, March 17, 2009 11:39 AM

I've always been very fond of the Viribus Unitis class, as it represented a very economical solution to the problem of getting maximum utility from the guns mounted, and the super-firing triple gun turrets is an outstanding solution well in advance of other navies of the time! Of course, there is no point in producing model ships of one navy without some opposing forces, so of course an Italian dreadnought is a must as well..... As for the list as a whole, certainly there are many more ships I would like to see (SMS Blucher, HMS Tiger, HMS Courageous, etc), but I think as a basis to work from, it provides a good overview of all the 'main players!'

Reply

warshipguy

Member since
September 2005
From: Groton, CT

Posted by warshipguy on Tuesday, March 17, 2009 11:21 AM

Eric,

Excellent list! I couldn't help but notice the equally ignored Mediterranean ships!

Bill Morrison

Reply

searat12

Member since
March 2007
From: Portsmouth, RI

WW1 Ships we'd all like to see!!

Posted by searat12 on Tuesday, March 17, 2009 9:46 AM

Although the world economy is in the crapper these days, perhaps we would not be too far remiss in putting in our requests for future production now! As there have been many threads addressing the various WW2 and later ships, I thought a separate thread just for WW1 (and earlier) might be a good thing, as this is a shamefully ignored period among model producers (other than the high-priced specialty resin manufacturers), and really should be addressed!

Here is my first stab at a list in order of preference for 1/350 scale, and I'm sure there are many others who will chime in as well. A quick note for any manufacturers that may read this, it is almost essential that models be produced simultaneously from both sides and not just from one!!:

BRITISH:

BC HMS Lion

BB HMS Iron Duke

SS 'E' Class submarine

BC HMS Invincible

BB Queen Elizabeth

BB Dreadnought

BB Orion

ACR HMS Good Hope

CL HMS Glasgow

SS 'K' class submarine

GERMAN:

BC SMS Derfflinger

ACR SMS Scharnhorst

SS U-Cruiser U-139

BC SMS Moltke

BB SMS Friederich Der Grosse

SS U-Boat U-35

BB SMS Helgoland

CL SMS Breslau

BC SMS Von Der Tann

BC SMS Seydlitz

CL SMS Leipzig

OTHER SHIPS:

BB Viribus Unitus

BB Conte de Cavour

BB USS New York

ACR USS Brooklyn

ACR Asama

ACR Bayan

Reply

THE MAGAZINE

CONTACT US

RECENT ARTICLES

POPULAR TOPICS

RECENT REVIEWS

POPULAR TOPICS

RECENT REVIEWS

POPULAR TOPICS

RECENT VIDEOS

POPULAR TOPICS

RECENT THREADS

CATEGORIES

NEW PRODUCTS

OUR STORE

CURRENT ISSUE

SEARCH FINESCALE.COM