Rusty,
Thanks for the clear description of your process. Simple sounds good to me. You've confirmed for me that painting the decks and fittings before assembly is a reasonable approach, and it seems to make sense to assemble and paint all the superstructure subassemblies (island structures, turrets, etc.) separately and then attach them to the previously painted deck. My experience with the fit of Tamiya kits makes me think gaps will be minimal, and if I use your approach--- not painting the superstructure elements and careful gluing--- I would expect the result would be cleaner demarcation lines between horizontal and vertical surfaces. Considering that you avoid a large portion of the masking that Mike Ashey's approach would require--- it sounds like an approach worth trying.
Tom
Tom- Glad to help. BTW, after painting the decks, I wound up painting all the exposed fittings as the bare plastic looked way out of place with all the darker superstructures.
BondoMan- I am right at the point I have to decide about paint schemes, weathering, metal parts, etc. I've been doing a lot of research! I started looking for rails when I noticed the deck already had holes for them, and still am not sure what I will do.
Ed- Thanks for the flag website. I've been thinking of making my own by printing out some website signal flags using a laserjet, and gluing them onto either wavey foil or shaped plasticard squares.
So many options; so few skills!
Rusty