I used to use Tamiya tape and Maskol all the time, till I stumbled onto BMF masking, and now Foil is all I use.
I find it to be excellent adhesion, great for curves, has absolutely no bleed under, and leaves a crisp paint line after removal.
Yes it is a little high in price, but I have used barely 1/8th of a sheet, and have done 12 models with it.
Mind you I only use Foil for canopies, and Tamiya tape for everything else.
It really is a case of trying it out for yourself, like most things in modeling.