Book / reference forum ? ( We would like a admin to have a look at this )

Isolating referances would be a good thing. Sticky theads like "online stores", "members' sites", and then popular subjects as an idea developes as to the most wanted refs. would be good to start. Do you guys think moving old threads that would better suited to the ref. forum would be a good idea??

Thanks for your input cass.
Moving old threads to a new reference forum! hmmm maybe it would be a good idea. there is alot of threads at the moment that should be in a reference forum, but in the end its up to the admins..........wish they would reply to this thread.
Anyway this is the kind of input that we need. Thanks cass.

You're welcome. Makes sense to consolidate referances. As the forum grows it'll have to be broken up for sanities sake. Referances have been piling up lately. I can't recall the newest forum, might be the welcome/intro forum.

monrad,

I will support a poll also

Richard

Ausf,Rishard,
Firstly the only way us Brits will eat herring is Kippers, Guinness, is known as Guinness, we have another called Murphys bit like a thin Guinness, do you have it in the USA?
Ausf, damm we were in NY last week if I had my head on we could have met! and sorted Kursk out properly! T34's PAH!
Bit late into this but I think its a great idea any reply from Lawrence yet It would be good if FSM could set up a catalogue of reference material, we can pray and hope!
Another well known site to do with underwater craft ( no advertising) has regular book reviews and ratings by members perhaps we could do something like that?Just think Ausf you could do a book review on Shermans ha! ha! how do you get minus 5 stars!

Regards to you all
Nick Kaths partner

kath! or should I say Nick! Thanks for your input.
You are not late, the more input the better.

Thanks Monrad, where about in Denmark are you from I? visited Copenhagen many years ago the little Mermaid etc I seem to remember a converted car that was use as an armoured car by the Danish resistance, parked near the police station mind you I am going back 25 years! Is it still there?
And my compliments to your city it has one of the most beautiful harbour entrances I have ever seen

Kath, I used to bartend in a place that had Murphy's on draught and the owner didn't mind if I partook towards the end of the night, oh happy times.
years ago there was a publication I subscribed to named 'Divers speak out', where members gave their input on equipment and resorts. It was expensive but completely unbiased because they didn't rely on advertisement dollars. That was before the web, I'm sure there are plenty of them now online.
Monrad, Here there's no 'd' on the end but it's the same stuff. Pure heaven. Around the holidays I get it 'fresh', although dare I admit, from a Norwegian (may Odin forgive me)
Kippers here are just huge sardines.

But are they smoked as in oak smoked ,not like cigars!
I now have a mental picture of someone trying to light a kipper O Lord where's the prozac!

Skinned, deboned, smoked and jammed into a tin....It's ok in a pinch but you don't want to make a habit out of it.

True its not as much fun as a burning Sherman!
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONNOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
I've entered the dark side

1st Kath, Nick.....whatever....both of you. I live in a city called Aalborg, thats 300 km from Copenhagen. I lived in Copenhagen for 3 years so I know it, and there is no armored car anymore. If you ever get to go to Denmark again then let me know and I'll meet you........doesn't matter where it is.
2nd maybe we should start a " food and beer forum "


I haven't heard from Lawrence yet, but I have had a bit of trouble with my mail so maybe he didn't get it, or maybe he is just to busy.....I bet he has other things to do than just read his mail and look at this forum.
I'll try again, and if nothing happens then maybe one of you guys should try.
What about the poll?????

BTW thanks for your mail Kath / Nick.

I have tried to send Lawrence a mail again, but nothing has happened.........guess there is something wrong with my mail server.........I recieve mails I just can't send any......I think its a problem with my firewall.
But could some of you try to contact him or maybe David Voss.

monrad,

I posted a question for Lawerence on the Community Assistance forum. Let's see what happens.

Richard

I saw your post Richard, and I have also replied.
Thanks Richard.
Still nothing from the admins.

Here's another post of support from an American. I saw a great post that led me to a fantastic sight that had vid clips of Russian equipment like a 'Grad' firing, and T-90 driving and firing. There were a ton more that I never got to see since I lost the thread, and a search came up empty. I thought i bookmarked it topo, but I have so many I have yet to find it.

This new Forum wouyld be fantastic!

That would be great! I think it would help all of us so that way we can go to book shop and have a list of what books you already want instead of having to read the book in the store to find out if thats what you want. You would already know what books to get. I think we should set up a refference forum.

monrad,

I sent Lawrence an e-mail today. Let's see what happens. It looks as if you are continuing to get more support for the forum.

Richard

Once again; Thanks Richard I realy appreciate your help.
So far 15 members have shown their support here, and thanks to all.
Compared to other threads this is quite good.
More support would be nice. The admins MUST notice this thread soon.

Monrad,

Why not have the admin guys, sticky a thread on book resources in the Off Topic Forum or General Modeling Discussion Forum. This way it will be there in an always accessible place. Always at the top and won't be moved 5 pages back. This way the admin guys can see how much traffic it will get and it will let them know if it warrants its own forum. Act as a moderator for a while and try to keep the postings focused on relavent info rather than a segue on good beers and pickled herring. It will give you a better measurement of use and activity and if it gets alot of traffic then more validity to your request. If not then the sticky can be removed and the issue becomes moot.

Mike

Thats a good idea mike; Thanks.
We have people here with alot of good ideas, now we just need the admins to read this.

Sounds like a great idea to me. Perhaps it could be linked to some kind of reference database? I don't know what the practical difficulties would be but it would be an invaluable resource for research

Personally I have more or less 17000 books and magazines.

I am used that people from everywhere asks me how is book "x" where can I find info about vehicle "y".

It is therefore one of the things that can really add value to this forum as books are pricey and budjts are short.

For example I have over 30 books on the F/A-18 Hornet. They were bought during two decades, but if someone asks what is the best book about the Hornet? I will be very glad to show him the differences between the best books, and tell him my preferences even if his taste is diferrent than mine. If we have different tastes he will ask me oppinions about other tittles rather than my favorite.

I absolutly agree with the idea! Hope the Kalmbach freindly guys will bring this idea to ife!

That makes it 18 members, Thanks guys.

monrad,

I am going to persue this issue until we get an answer even if it is negative

I sent an e-mail to FSM reqesting an answer. I feel that we should not be ignored I am now going to make this a personal issue for the both of us If it causes a problem for me in regards to the forum so be it We are here to be assisted by the administrators so where are they

Hope this helps

Richard

I have the same feelings Richard.

I have seen admins in the forums several times also in suggestions and feedback, but nothing has happened. I am begining to feel overlooked.

I don't want to pass judgement, maybe there is a good reason, but it is frustrating.
I am very excited about this and would like to see it happen, I hope the admins will show us some interest soon.

Hi folks~

I apologize for the long delay in responding to this thread. FSM staff activity on the Forum isn't a question of interest; it's one of time. As many of you know, April was a big month of travel for us (it's THE month for model shows). I was away for a week and a half (AMPS was part of the itinerary--OnlineEXTRA gallery to come), and the others have been on the road for shows as much or more. The deadlines for the print magazine always come first, so this was one of those times when we couldn't give the website as much attention as we'd like to.

However, since I got back, I've at least kept up with the discussion here for a references forum, and it seems like a good idea. My concern was where to put it and how to structure it. The criteria for new topics have to be very strict: they must be well-defined and not likely to siphon off discussion from the main modeling subject areas. But I'm also concerned about getting too many sticky topics at the top of each modeling subject forum, so I've opted for adding a Reference Materials forum to Tools and Techniques area (which has now been renamed accordingly): http://www.finescale.com/fsm/community/forum/forum.asp?FORUM_ID=28

Consider this a "beta test": let's drive it a while and see how it works.

THANK YOU Lawrence. This is all that we asked for.
Like I said above, there may be a good reason that you haven't answered this before now and apperently there was.
Thanks for your kind reply, I will post in that reference forum soon.
I think we can stop the discusion here now that we have gotten what we wanted.
Thanks for all the input guys.