Just need some opinion

Whoa, the replies are awesome !

Thanks to everyone for your helpful suggestions And ya, im fourteen, turning fifthteen soon

Oh and I know I dont really have good lighting. I'll most likely use my workbench light for futur pics.

Thanks again

You did some really good work Ben.  Keep it up and don't be shy about posting pics and asking questions.

Aaron Skinner

Ben,

Those are good looking builds. I don't remember anything I built when I was 14 looking as nice. Keep it up.

Cheers, Aaron

Oh I remember mine looking that good - - - but they weren't!

It's great to see new, young talent coming out like this. At age 14, this is better than a lot of older guys' work that I've seen on this and other sites!

Congratulations on a fine little collection. Just one critique--try to get a little brighter lighting for your photos to show off your finishing skill a little better!

Ben,

Those are good looking builds. I don't remember anything I built when I was 14 looking as nice. Keep it up.

Cheers, Aaron

Nice Job Ben ! Keep em coming !   oops.. your underage... try this..

Looking good to my eyes Ben. Nothing to be ashamed of at all with any of them at any age!

Great builds buddy, and the weathering looks spot-on to me - really warn without looking fake, it's a fine line that you seem to have a good feel for. Keep it up!

tigerman

Some really good work for any age, let alone 14.

I agree. 

Ben, you did a bang up job on all of them (speaking as a member who is 3 times your age with about 1/3 your weathering skills).  If you want to take your skills to another level, check out Karl Logan's work (screen name Doog). His weathering is fantastic and his builds have been published in FSM several times.  Keep it up and you'll be giving him a run for his money.

Paul

Some really good work for any age, let alone 14.

Thnx for posting your work.  One suggestion for you: remember that these are supposed to be actual working machines. In the case of the Shilka: you can't blank off periscopes, air intakes, exhausts, or limit the elevation or traverse of the guns.  Defeats the whole purpose, no?

Always try to think: If I were a tanker, what would I leave handy and clear?  Hope this helps

Fantastic work!! I love the burned out t-62.

Cheers...

Ben

Outstanding work all around. Lets start at the top . The Soviet export / arab vehicle. It is beautiful the omision of the external tanks is a nice touch. The vehicle also shows a realistic level of weathering , wear and general neglect that would be seen on vehicles in the region.

The matilda simply stunning . The holes on the left front fender, are those for tool mounts . Just throw a little stowage on and cover those. The weathering and wear is outstanding.

The Shilka.......... well I am guessing you used faux fur . The effect is a great idea. i would take scisors and trim the fur down severly at random heights . Then add some visual interest by using long bristles from a paint brush added in small groups . This will give height differences as well as a subtle color shift .

Whatever you do keep building and posting your work . You are a great modeler .

Ben323

Hey guys,

These are some of my models. I'm 14 and just wanted to know some opinions on them

Ben- 14?  Oh maybe it was a typo... you meant to type 41, right?  No way a 14 years old boy can do those.  I built models when I was your age and they were no where close to yours.  You have talent and you will enjoy your time here at FSM.  Learn all of great tips from those masters...

Matilda is definitely my favorite...  

Thanks for sharing Ben!Welcome aboard and I look forward to seeing more of your fantastic work. There is lots of talent here to learn from and it looks like you are well on your way already. Just don't let the pic thing happen again... Just kidding!

Ya your right, thought there isnt much up there. I'll give it a haircut

Oh and sorry about the pictures. It was my first time posting pictures so i din't know better

Thanks btw

Ben, you have some great talent there at 14 already! Your work is quite impressive for any age,and more so because of your youth I agree about the hay on the turret of the Shilka. Way too much up top.  Some around the edges to breakup the outline on the panniers is fine but in the center it starts to get in the way of various functions such as hatches,optics, etc. Also as a favor, I would suggest you post your pics stacked vertically rather than side by side as you did here. Its much easier to scroll up and down to view them rather than work them side to side with the cursor and the mouse.

Ben -

I think your weathering skills are excellent. On the par at the least with many of those who show their kits on the site. The Matilda has the sense of a well beaten desert warrior. My knowledge on modern era Soviet vehicles is sparse as best, even though I like the treatments that you have done to portrayal of these vehicles.

The degree of weathering is a personal choice and don't let others say otherwise. With more modern subjects, the degree of weathering may be alot less than seen in previous times. This is because of the modern paints, crew maintanence, etc. That comes from reading the comments from the members who were actually in or have seen the vehicles in action. But it is an art form and express yourself in the way that you feel about it. You have the chops.

My best on your future projects, you have the talent and more. Good luck to you.

Mike T.

Tojo72

I really like the Matilda,you did a nice job with the camo,weathering is good as is the chipping.I would loose the hay on the Shilka,let the model be seen !!  Just my thoughts.

But,hey great work overall,and welcome to the forums.You can learn a lot here and dont stop posting your work.

well the "hay" (lol) is there because the kit itself is a really horrible kit with hardly any detail , at least my copy was.

But thanks !

Thanks guys, your opinion means a lot

I really like the Matilda,you did a nice job with the camo,weathering is good as is the chipping.I would loose the hay on the Shilka,let the model be seen !!  Just my thoughts.

But,hey great work overall,and welcome to the forums.You can learn a lot here and dont stop posting your work.

Dang Ben!

I'm no expert but I really like those!

My opinion? I want a peanut butter sandwich.

All jokes aside, they're pretty awesome.