Sprue-ce Goose:
Well the bottom line is... a full-on ACL replacement would take a year to recover from, the knee would still never be 100%, and I'd still have to wear the brace to be sure of non-injury. Leaving it as-is, continuing with at-home physio, bike & ball while wearing the brace... may accomplish darn-near the same thing without having to run the risk of a surgery.
(That being said, the Dr. I'm lined up with is an ACL pro, highly regarded on this end of the country. I'm supposed to follow up with her after the ball season wraps up.)
Frig, I am a codger. Anybody got some spare prune juice??