I would have to say that both of them are quality renditions of that classic scene.
I'm going to have a slight change in plan. My choice of aircraft gray won't work because I don't have enough paint in the bottle and I don't know when I'll be able to make it to a hobby shop. So I'm going with a back up of dark aircraft gray from a rattle can. On the bright side, no one can show me a real TIE and tell me I'm wrong